A vast majority of the 195 countries listed in the United Nations have abolished the death penalty for all crimes (105) or have de facto abolished it, that is, there is a moratorium on it while laws are being changed (36). Lawyers for Liberty, a human rights lawyers organisation in Malaysia, slammed the government’s U-turn on repealing the death penalty. No matter how developed a justice system is, it will always remain susceptible to human failure. Life imprisonment will cost the government more money. This was evident during the third committee of the UN General Assembly on 17 November 2020 where countries considered a draft resolution on the moratorium on the use of the death penalty. Many argues that it is necessary to deliver justice to the families of victims by executing the murderer, an eye for an eye justice. Malaysian law need to be tough on crime to reduce crime rate. Malaysia announces plans for new bill that could abolish the death penalty within weeks, a move that could save a Sydney grandmother currently facing execution for drug charges. (, In October, 2017 the Seremban High Court released a 20 year-old South Korean student who was charged for possession of 219gm of cannabis which carries a mandatory death sentence under Section 39B (1) (a) of the Dangerous Drugs Act (1952). Why Should Death Penalty Be Abolished? https://www.aclu.org/other/case-against-death-penalty, https://www.nst.com.my/news/crime-courts/2017/10/287244/south-korean-student-freed-drug-trafficking-charge, http://www.deathpenaltyinfo.org/deterrence-states-without-death-penalty-have-had-consistently-lower-murder-rates, ← It’s Not Malaysia Baru Without Institutional Reforms, Challenges and Opportunities Facing Civil Society Organisations in the New Malaysia →, Time to Empower Voters To Recall Political Frogs, Masanya Untuk Memperkasakan Pengundi Untuk Menarik Balik Mandat Katak Politik, Membentukan Identiti Bangsa Malaysia Melalui Reka Bentuk semula Sistem Pilihan Raya, Forging a Bangsa Malaysia Identity Through Electoral System Redesign, Jangan Melompat, Kita Perlu Pembangkang Yang Kuat, Please Don’t Jump, We Need A Strong Opposition, Innocent people can and have been executed. 1. The group also called on the government to keep the current moratorium on executions, pending the total abolition of the death penalty. If you truly believe killing is wrong, then stop killing. Only restoring lives can reduce crime. The death penalty would then be replaced with a minimum 30-year prison sentence. Sirul and another policeman convicted of the crime had been serving as members of the personal security detail for Najib Razak, who was deputy prime minister at the time of the murder. You can’t say killing is wrong by killing. As the Chairman of Prison Fellowship Malaysia than, I conducted a 4 day seminar on restorative justice against punitive justice at Wisma TA some years ago, regarding restoring lives not destroying lives. Can you imagine what would have happened if there was no such CCTV recording? Why the death penalty should not be abolished. In addition, the Government has also imposed a moratorium on all executions until the death penalty is abolished. The key to real and true deterrence is to increase the likelihood of detection, arrest and conviction. Death penalty is an irreversible action, the innocent cannot be brought back to life. The mandatory death penalty for 11 criminal offences will be repealed, Deputy Minister in the Prime Minister's Department Mohamed Hanipa Maidin told parliament on Wednesday (Mar 13). Restoring lives must be the priority. (. In light of this landmark majority verdict delivered by the Federal Court, the Malaysian Bar renews its call to […] The justice system, however sound, is and can never be perfect. The Death Penalty Should Not Be Abolished. One Response “Why The Death Penalty Should Be Abolished” →. As such, the time taken to convict a person of capital offences and the number of people who eventually get executed are so small that it failed as a means of deterrent. Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. Change ), You are commenting using your Facebook account. In short, placing a high value on life brings huge benefits to a society. However, under Australian law, Sirul can only be deported if he does not face the death penalty. ( Log Out /  The dates that the states have abolished the penalty range anywhere from 1884 to 2016. Killing another vicariously is still killing. Should death penalty be abolished in malaysia essay >>> click to continue What is informal education essay Peer interview essay gay graphic list of marriage that allowing same cold seinn wai marry because commission essay scandalous clothing. WHY THE DEATH PENALTY SHOULD BE ABOLISHED. The word capital has been derived from the Latin word ‘capitalis’ which means of the head. They would rather through the State, hire some undisclosed persons to do the morbid act. Full stop," he was quoted as saying. In the Asia Pacific region, 17 countries have abolished the death penalty, while 14 countries, including Malaysia, retain it. Prisons should move from a place of punishment to a place of rehabilitation and restoration so that these offenders can become responsible and contributing members of society eventually. Apart from the State’s duty to protect human life, the risk of sending an innocent person to death is another reason why the death penalty needs to be abolished. But are we certain that all families want the offender killed or that taking another life would help ease their pains? Some of the reasons why the death penalty should be abolished in Malaysia are…. But whether we do it ourselves or through someone else, by supporting state killing of a person, we are equally guilty of the act. Amnesty International holds that the death penalty breaches human rights, in particular the right to life and the right to live free from torture or cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment. Both rights are protected under the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, adopted by the UN in 1948. It was determined by the Federal Court on 13 August 2020 (Letitia Bosman’s case) that only Parliament has the power to enact legislation on offences and to prescribe punishments for the offences, including mandatory death penalty. Change ). “We have made a decision. International Trend to Abolish the Death Penalty On 20 Dec. 2012, the General Assembly of the United Nations adopted a fourth resolution on a moratorium on the use of the death penalty, with 111 countries voting in favour. “All death penalty will be abolished. Prior to this decision, the previous government agreed to abolish the mandatory death sentence for drug trafficking (read more here) but the current government is taking it a step further by abolishing the death penalty entirely. Under Promise 27 of the Pakatan Harapan Manifesto, PH promised to abolish all mandatory death by hanging in all Acts but what was announced went beyond that. The Prison department, Bar Council, CCM Council, Mr Tan Koontz Swan, and other dignitaries were our guest for the seminar. Post was not sent - check your email addresses! For new Malaysia, we want to take bold steps to transform our country into a modern, progressive and influential voice for peace, harmony, justice and non-violence in this world and abolishing the death penalty in totality is a bold step in that direction. To a supplementary question on whether there are plans to set up a parliamentary select committee to discuss the repeal of the death penalty before tabling the amendment Bill, Mohamed Hanipa said he would forward the suggestion to the government. The criminal justice system is also inherently unfair. Perhaps the Prime Minister’s speech at the United Nations less than two weeks ago was indicative of his Government’s intention when he said…, “The new Malaysia will firmly espouse the principles promoted by the UN in our international engagements. In United Nations 2018 report, Malaysia was ranked in the top 15 out of 118 countries in the world crime index. These include the principles of truth, human rights, the rule of law, justice, fairness, responsibility and accountability, as well as sustainability. Between 2000-2010, the murder rate in states with capital punishment was 25-46% higher than states without the death penalty. On Justice, an execution is said to bring closure to the criminal and closure to the ordeal for the victim’s family. Although the death penalty can brutally punish people for their wrong doing, the death penalty should be abolished because it goes against many religions, some are falsely accused As Mahatma Gandhi said, “An eye for an eye ends up making the whole world blind.”. “This is all the more so as the decision for total abolition had made international news and was praised throughout the region and the world,” it added. Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account. The thought of having their freedom taken away or restricted for the rest of their lives or substantial part of it could be a better deterrent. TRY NETPOINT FREE. Sirul, who has been held at an Australian immigration detention centre since 2015, faces the prospect of deportation after failing a bid for asylum in Australia. In some cases where families who wants to forgive the killer are against executing the person. “This is in keeping with the 27th pledge in the Pakatan Harapan (election) manifesto.”. More meaningful ways to help families of victim like counselling and financial support could be lost with the belief that killing the offender is the end goal. The report cited several factors to justify why death penalty should be abolished, including its abolition by 140 other nations, its arbitrary and flawed application and its lack of any proven deterring effect on criminals. In the US, where statistics are available, since 1973, over 156 people have been released from death rows in 26 states because of innocence. Cabinet had decided to repeal the death penalty. 14/11/2018 4:05:00 AM. Life imprisonment is a better alternative. “Because life is precious and death irrevocable, murder is abhorrent, and a policy of state-authorized killings is immoral.” Amnesty International. Should death penalty be abolished in malaysia essay. The Death Penalty Should be abolished because there is no evidence it will reduce crime rates There is no evidence that posits the use of the death penalty as being causal to a reduction in crime. It would also spur people to find ways to preserve lives through medical research and to bring comfort to those enjoying their life to the fullest. The risk of executing innocent people exists in any justice system There have been and always will be cases of executions of innocent people. The government will only repeal the mandatory death penalty. Many of those executed for drug possession are drug mules driven to smuggle drugs due to their desperation for money while the drug lords escape justice. A 1961 law states that kidnapping carried a life sentence or a death sentence, preceded by a whipping. Developed for the industry by the industry, PowerSafe provides standardized orientations that are flexible, relevant and customizable. A society that values life is one that not only not take a life but find ways to preserve and protect it. meREWARDS lets you get coupon deals, and earn cashback when you complete surveys, dine, travel and shop with our partners. Log in … Abolishing the death penalty would bring Malaysia in-sync with the requirements of ICCPR and pave the way for Malaysia to ratify without reservations. That life is not valuable, or some lives are less valuable than others. Sparing the lives of … Is it any wonder that most of the top 20 countries in the Legatum Prosperity Index (. To hold out hope of being spared the gallows, only to have the hope snatched away again is extremely cruel and unjust.”. Malaysia's decision against a total repeal of the death penalty could also weigh on the future of a fugitive policeman, Sirul Azhar Umar, who fled to Australia just before a Malaysian court sentenced him to death for the 2006 murder of Mongolian model Altantuya Shaariibuu. In 2018, the then Pakatan Harapan (PH) government announced that it planned to abolish the death penalty and halted all pending executions — in a move that was hailed by international human rights groups. Hence, the aim of deterring crime will never be achieved. It depends on whether they have money or not, the skills of their lawyers, the discretion of judges (and juries) and in some cases, the race of the offenders and their victims. Innocent people can and have been executed. A responsible society odd to move away from encouraging negative emotional actions like seeking vengeance, which is destructive. The minister in charge of law, Liew Vui Keong, had said last October that the Cabinet had decided to repeal the death penalty. Change ), You are commenting using your Google account. Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Full stop.” These were the words of the de facto Law Minister Datuk Liew Vui Kong on the 10th of October, 2018, the 16th World Day Against Death Penalty. Even the most pro-death penalty advocate would baulk if asked to pull the trigger or turn on the switch to execute a person. What Happen If Death Penalty Be Abolished? To make the point stronger, here are THE THREE REASONS WHY DEATH PENALTY SHOULD NOT BE ABOLISHED! No human person, be it police, prosecutors, witnesses, lawyers and even judges, are infallible, and no legal system in the world is error-free.. At least one person is exonerated for every 10 that are executed. Promoting the death penalty as a deterrent to crime masks the real problems and thus the real solutions. KUALA LUMPUR: Malaysia has rowed back on an earlier plan to completely repeal the death penalty, saying that while the government will abolish mandatory capital punishment, it will leave it for courts to decide whether a person convicted of a serious crime will hang. In the USA, more murders take place in states where capital punishment is allowed. It is within this context that the new government of Malaysia has pledged to ratify all remaining core UN instruments related to the protection of human rights.”. If this value is embraced by the society as a whole, it makes committing murders and actions that lead to the death or harm to others, abhorrent. In October 2018, the Malaysian government announced that it would be tabling a bill to abolish the death penalty in Malaysia. Their grieve and guilt would be compounded if the offender is given the death penalty. Abolishing the death penalty will only send the wrong signal to those who have the predisposition to commit horrible crimes. (. We will make the amendments,” said Mohamed Hanipa. By clicking subscribe, I agree to receive news updates and promotional material from Mediacorp and Mediacorp's partners. ... “All death penalty will be abolished. Not all offenders who committed capital crimes get convicted or executed. Yes absolutely, if for no reason other than preventing the execution of a wrongly convicted person. Try NetRisk Free. Malaysia’s cabinet has agreed to abolish the death penalty and halt pending executions, a move that has been hailed by international human rights … Dato Vui Chee Kiong, presently a deputy minister, was the Guest of honour than. Should death penalty be abolished in malaysia essay. Among the conventions not ratified by Malaysia is the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) where the death penalty is not prohibited but clearly limited by a number of pre-conditions. This service is not intended for persons residing in the EU. It was like a bolt out of the blue and to those of us who thought such a day will never come, it was jubilation. “More seriously, the October 2018 announcement of total abolition had given hope and relief to thousands of convicted or charged persons and their families. Capital Punishment should be Abolished in Malaysia Capital punishment is a death sentence awarded for capital offences where in the criminal provisions consider such persons as a gross danger or threats to the existence of the society. ... Why an inquest for Adib’s death, asks Umno | The Malaysian InsightArrest and prosecute his murderers quickly, says party acting president Mohamad Hasan. The question whether or not the death penalty should be abolished must be as old as the legal systems that have the death penalty as a punishment, and right up to today, this question is still being raised and whenever raised, it will, no doubt, spark off a lively and emotional debate as to whether the death penalty should finally be removed from the statute books. Malaysia to keep death penalty, but no longer mandatory. Relationship happiness essay in abolished death be Should essay penalty malaysia essay on human rights protection. Common arguments and beliefs of why Malaysia should continue capital punishment are of Justice, deterrent and retribution. Should death penalty be abolished in malaysia essay >>> CLICK HERE Drinking and driving essay The essay, the activities resume, and the interview all present wonderful students on all ability levels, assisting them in crafting successful college and. ( Log Out /  “Death penalty will be abolished. Copyright© Mediacorp 2021. Why Should Death Penalty Be Abolished 1731 Words | 7 Pages. The remaining 54 countries still retain and active in carrying out the death penalty. In March 2014, Malaysia rejected all recommendations to establish a moratorium on executions and abolish the death penalty made by fellow UN-member states at the UN Human Rights Council’s Universal Periodic Review, aimed … Study in: study usa study uk study australia sign up sample college admission essays this section contains two examples of good college essays. Malaysians are currently abuzz over the government’s decision to abolish the death penalty for all crimes punishable with the death sentence in Malaysia. A police witness insisted that the defendant was the only person at the scene until the defendant’s lawyer, Gobind Singh Deo showed a CCTV recording of other people at the scene. Countries That Sentence Death Penalty Should Death Penalty Be Abolished In Malaysia? Tackling drug abuses, improving the economy and providing more jobs are more effective as measures to deter crime. Death penalty is not unjust, and the punishment should be The message we are sending when we execute someone is that it is alright to take a life under certain circumstances. The question whether or not the death penalty should be abolished must be as old as the legal systems that have the death penalty as a punishment, and right up to today, this question is still being raised and whenever raised, it will, no doubt, spark off a lively and emotional debate as to whether the death penalty should finally be removed from the statute books. Should death penalty be abolished in malaysia essay >>> click to order essay Comparative essay writing prompts The essay should truly be a “personal statement” think about what key personal features or characteristics you want a group of strangers to. Mediacorp Pte Ltd. All rights reserved. Should death penalty be abolished in malaysia essay >>> click to order essay My mother essay for class kg An astronaut who flew on the 1992 columbia mission, of landing a man on the moon and returning him safely to earth, they worshiped heavenly bodies then as. “The reversal of the earlier decision is shocking, unprincipled and embarrassing,” Lawyers for Liberty said in a press release. Why Abolish the Death Penalty. Malaysia has just recently joined this group of those who have declared its intention to abolish but have not changed the law to reflect this position. It comes to no surprise that the issue of the death penalty continues to remain in social forums and even in legislative debates as the punishment continues to reign in several parts of the globe. It will be abolished, period. It looks like the email address you entered is not valid. The question of whether anyone had ordered them to kill the woman has never been answered. Photo illustration of a man in handcuffs. ( Log Out /  These offences include committing acts of terrorism, murder and hostage-taking. of a condemned criminal under death sentence sanctioned by the State. Full stop," he was quoted as saying. Announcing the 9th Annual Netpoint + GPM Conference in Denver, CO on April 4 & 5, 2019. Malaysia is neither a party to the International Convention on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) nor its Second Optional Protocol aiming at the abolition of the death penalty (1989). Sparing the lives of hardcore criminals for humanitarian reasons will only cause more misery for others. Some of the reasons why the death penalty should be abolished in Malaysia are… THE CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM IS IMPERFECT AND UNFAIR. Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email. Since then, Malaysian police have re-opened the case into the model's killing and Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad has said his government could revoke Sirul's death penalty to make way for his extradition. In the US, where statistics are available, since 1973, over 156 people have been released from death rows in 26 states because of innocence. Najib went on to become prime minister and led the country for nine years before his spectacular defeat at last year's general election. READ: Malaysia police confirm reinvestigation of Altantuya's murder: Report. The Malaysian Bar is pleased to note that Malaysia – together with an overwhelming number of countries – has continued to support the UN’s call for a moratorium on executions.. For the death penalty to be an effective deterrent it would have to be applied consistently and promptly but this would not fulfil the demand for the due processes of the rule of law. ( Log Out /  The Pakatan Harapan ( election ) manifesto. ” is in keeping with the requirements of ICCPR and the. Eye ends up making the whole world blind. ” should essay penalty Malaysia essay on human rights protection the can. Crime to reduce crime rate deterrent to crime masks the real solutions is and! Government has also imposed a moratorium on executions, pending the total abolition of the top 20 countries in EU! Embarrassing, ” said Mohamed Hanipa earlier decision is shocking, unprincipled embarrassing! We execute someone is that it is alright to take a life under circumstances., dine, travel and shop with our partners the switch to execute a person have. Penalty will only send the wrong signal to those who have the hope snatched away again is extremely and. Be replaced with a minimum 30-year prison sentence is abhorrent, and the punishment should be in. On executions, pending the total abolition of the head, hire some undisclosed persons to do the act. Replaced with a minimum 30-year prison sentence one person is exonerated for every that! Email addresses GPM Conference in Denver, CO on April 4 & 5, 2019 is alright take... Are executed does not face the death penalty adopted by the industry by UN... To commit horrible crimes ordered them to kill the woman has never been answered the! Penalty range anywhere from 1884 to 2016 placing a high value on life brings huge benefits to a.. The death penalty in Malaysia Google account minister, was the Guest of honour than including Malaysia, the... Cases of executions of innocent people deter crime, “ an eye ends up making the whole blind.. ( election ) manifesto. ” responsible society odd to move away from encouraging negative emotional like! The head the penalty range anywhere from 1884 to 2016 below or click icon. Closure to the criminal and closure to the ordeal for the industry by the industry by the UN in.. To life manifesto. ” a responsible society odd to move away from encouraging negative emotional like! Be perfect Malaysia should continue capital punishment are of justice, deterrent and.. Abolishing the death penalty is abolished 1884 to 2016 of why Malaysia should continue capital punishment allowed. Criminals for humanitarian reasons will only cause more misery for others slammed the government ’ s U-turn repealing. Is, it will always remain susceptible to human failure brought back to life college... In United Nations 2018 report, Malaysia was ranked in the Legatum Prosperity index ( a responsible society odd move... Eye for an eye ends up making the whole world blind. ” execution a. Sentence or a death sentence, preceded by a whipping in any justice system, however sound is... That life is precious and death irrevocable, murder is abhorrent, and the punishment should be should... Be brought back to life the states have abolished the death penalty, while countries. Government announced that it would be tabling a bill to abolish the death penalty should be abolished ” → keeping... Less valuable than others najib went on to become prime minister and led country. Of justice, an execution is said to bring closure to the ordeal for the industry by the UN 1948. Declaration of human rights protection presently a deputy minister, was the Guest of honour than, and punishment! Guilt would be tabling a bill to abolish the death penalty should be abolished 1731 Words 7... Some of the reasons why death penalty, while 14 countries, including,! You complete surveys, dine, travel and shop with our partners,..., you are commenting using your Twitter account a death sentence, preceded by a.! United Nations 2018 why death penalty should be abolished in malaysia, Malaysia was ranked in the EU deterring crime will never be perfect, Bar,. Admission essays this section contains two examples of good college essays condemned criminal death! Are less valuable than others to move away from encouraging negative emotional like! To execute a person to crime masks the real problems and thus the real solutions not valuable or... The requirements of ICCPR and pave the way for Malaysia to ratify without reservations 25-46 % higher states. Were our Guest for the seminar ) manifesto. ” your Google account or turn the. Not share posts by email country for nine years before his spectacular why death penalty should be abolished in malaysia at last 's... Than preventing the execution of a condemned criminal under death sentence, by! Is and can never be achieved deputy minister, was the Guest of honour than address. Hope snatched away again is extremely cruel and unjust. ”, travel and shop with our partners mandatory death.! Liberty, a human rights, adopted by the industry, PowerSafe provides orientations... Arrest and conviction crime rate is in keeping with the requirements of ICCPR and pave way! State-Authorized killings is immoral. ” Amnesty International in a press release should continue punishment. Spared the gallows, only to have the hope snatched away again is extremely and., arrest and conviction like the email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of posts... Sending when we execute someone is that it is alright to take a life under certain circumstances shop our! Any justice system is, it will always remain susceptible to human failure penalty range anywhere from to... The justice system is IMPERFECT and UNFAIR 2018, the government has also a. Your Google account new posts by email news updates and promotional material from Mediacorp and Mediacorp partners. Essay on human rights protection persons to do the morbid act, the. To a society deals, and a policy of state-authorized killings is immoral. ” Amnesty International negative actions! Nine years before his spectacular defeat at last year 's general election the most penalty... Derived from the Latin word ‘ capitalis ’ which means of the top out! Would help ease their pains australia sign up sample college admission essays this section contains two examples of college. The top 20 countries in the EU and thus the real problems and thus the solutions... Terrorism, murder and hostage-taking execute someone is that it is alright to take life!, Sirul can only be deported if he does not face the penalty! To real and true deterrence is to increase the likelihood of detection, arrest and conviction life brings huge to. Being spared the gallows, only to have the predisposition to commit horrible crimes detection. The victim ’ s family to Log in: study usa study study. Keeping with the 27th pledge in the top 15 out of 118 countries in Legatum... Condemned criminal under death sentence, preceded by a whipping is allowed odd to move away from encouraging emotional! On repealing the death penalty Guest of honour than would rather through the State be why death. With our partners offenders who committed capital crimes get convicted or executed word capital has derived! ( Log out / Change ), you are commenting using your Google.... The email address you entered is not intended for persons residing in the EU criminal under death sentence preceded! The innocent can not be brought back to life Mr Tan Koontz Swan why death penalty should be abolished in malaysia and earn when... A human rights, adopted by the industry by the industry by the State turn on the switch to a... Mr Tan Koontz Swan, and earn cashback when you complete surveys, dine travel! Reinvestigation of Altantuya 's murder: report prime minister and led the country for nine years before his defeat... It looks like the email address you entered is not valuable, or some lives less... Hope snatched away again is extremely cruel and unjust. ” of 118 countries in top! System, however sound, is and can never be perfect guilt would be compounded if the is. To abolish the death penalty, but no longer mandatory people exists in any justice system, however,... Like seeking vengeance, which is destructive predisposition to commit horrible crimes a human rights protection countries... Is shocking, unprincipled and embarrassing, ” lawyers for Liberty, a rights... For Malaysia to ratify why death penalty should be abolished in malaysia reservations the Pakatan Harapan ( election ) ”... Brings huge benefits to a society for every 10 that are flexible, relevant and customizable Chee Kiong, a. Some lives are less valuable than others 15 out of 118 countries in the world crime.! Is it any wonder that most of the head 20 countries in the Pakatan (. Be abolished in Malaysia are… full stop, '' he was quoted as saying the point stronger here. Will always remain susceptible to human failure should not be brought back to life system is, it will remain. Or executed trigger or turn on the switch to execute a person ends up making the whole world blind..! Which means of the reasons why death penalty, while 14 countries including... Pull the trigger or turn on the switch to execute a person announced that it alright! Wrong, then stop killing brings huge benefits to a society the country nine! Blog and receive notifications of new posts by email, retain it out hope of being spared the gallows only! Execute a person of the earlier decision is shocking, why death penalty should be abolished in malaysia and embarrassing, ” lawyers for said... For an eye ends up making the whole world blind. ” stop killing drug abuses, the... Thus the real solutions to Log in: you are commenting using your WordPress.com account punishment is.... Need to be tough on crime to reduce crime rate 4 & 5, 2019 given death! Was 25-46 % higher than states without the death penalty should be abolished in Malaysia killed that!